Protecting the Mother-Infant Bond: A Call to the Realities of Adoption and Surrogacy
Adoption and surrogacy are often celebrated as modern miracles, compassionate solutions to unintended pregnancies and infertility. Adoption is praised for offering children loving homes and fulfilling the dreams of hopeful parents. Surrogacy is framed as an altruistic gift, a woman’s generous act to carry a child for another. Yet beneath these heartwarming narratives lies a profound and often ignored truth: both practices typically begin with the intentional separation of a mother and her infant. This rupture severs a bond that is not only sacred and biological but essential for emotional, psychological, and developmental well-being.
The mother-infant bond is a foundational human connection that begins in utero and continues long after birth. It is the earliest relationship a human experiences and lays the groundwork for attachment, security, and identity. Disrupting this bond, whether through adoption or surrogacy, carries long-lasting consequences for both mother and child. These consequences are too often minimized or overlooked in public discourse, policy, and practice.
This article is a call to the reality of adoption and surrogacy. It urges society to prioritize family preservation, protect children’s rights, and acknowledge the profound impact of separating mothers and infants. By listening to the voices of adoptees, birth mothers, surrogates, and the growing body of scientific research on attachment and prenatal development, we can reshape our approach with ethics, compassion, and respect for the sacred mother-infant bond.
The Biology and Psychology of Bonding
The bond between mother and child is not just an emotional connection, it is deeply biological and psychological. From the earliest stages of pregnancy, a unique relationship forms between the mother and her developing baby. The foetus becomes attuned to the mother’s voice, her heartbeat, her rhythms, and even her emotional state. Scientific studies show that by the second trimester, a foetus can recognize and respond to their mother’s voice, exhibiting changes in heart rate and movement.[i]
Foetal psychology further reveals that the unborn baby is actively learning in the womb. The mother’s voice, scent, and emotional tone create a familiar sensory environment that the baby is biologically primed to seek after birth. Babies are born with a preference for their mother’s voice and smell, and they are neurologically wired to seek proximity to her as a source of safety and comfort.
When a mother holds her newborn skin-to-skin, breastfeeds, and engages in eye contact, it triggers a hormonal cascade that includes the release of oxytocin, the so-called “love hormone.” This process deepens the attachment for both mother and infant, reducing stress and supporting neurodevelopment. These early experiences are not optional extras; they are fundamental to healthy development.
Disrupting this natural sequence through immediate post-birth separation, as is common in adoption and surrogacy, can have serious consequences. Infants may exhibit heightened cortisol levels (a stress hormone), feeding difficulties, and disturbed sleep patterns. Long-term effects include challenges with emotional regulation, attachment disorders, and a persistent sense of loss or disconnection.
The Unseen Grief of Birth Mothers and Surrogates
The grief of birth mothers and surrogates is rarely discussed in mainstream narratives. In adoption, birth mothers are often expected to disappear—praised for their “selfless choice” but given little space to process their loss. Many are discouraged from holding or even seeing their babies, under the guise of making the separation easier. But far from easing pain, this denial of connection often deepens the trauma.
One mother described waking every morning for decades with a deep, unexplainable ache, wondering where her child was and whether they were safe.[ii] Another spoke of being told to forget, to move on, as if motherhood could be erased with a signature. These women carry a lifelong wound compounded by societal silence and the lack of validation for their grief.
Surrogates face a different, yet similarly devastating, form of grief. Despite assurances that they will not become attached, especially in cases where they are not genetically related to the child, many report profound emotional distress after birth. Pregnancy involves physical transformation, emotional investment, and a deep biological connection, regardless of genetics. One surrogate shared how she was instructed not to hold the baby she delivered yet felt an overwhelming instinct to comfort and protect the newborn. Her grief was dismissed because the child was “never hers”, a denial of her lived and embodied experience.
These stories illuminate a critical truth: motherhood is not solely defined by legal contracts or genetics. It is forged through the intimate, transformative experience of carrying and birthing a child. To ignore this is to reduce women to vessels and deny their humanity.
Children Speak: The Voices of Adoptees and Surrogate-Born Adults
Adoption and surrogacy are often discussed from the perspective of adults seeking children. Rarely do we centre the voices of those most affected: the children themselves. But the experiences of adoptees and individuals born through surrogacy offer sobering insights into the lifelong impact of early separation.
Many adoptees describe a primal wound—a sense of abandonment and disconnection that persists even in the presence of loving adoptive families. One woman, adopted at birth, recounted how she always felt like a visitor in her own life, haunted by unanswered questions about her origins. She spoke of the moment she saw her biological mother’s face for the first time and felt a deep, visceral recognition—one that had been missing her entire life.
Similarly, adults born through surrogacy have spoken out about their struggles with identity and belonging. One man, born via an anonymous surrogacy arrangement, described feeling like a “purchased product.” He had no access to information about the woman who carried him and grew up with a deep sense of incompleteness. His existence, though cherished by his intended parents, was marked by a transaction that denied him knowledge of his origins.
These voices are not anomalies. They reflect a growing body of testimony from those who have lived the consequences of practices that prioritize adult desires over children’s rights. Their stories demand to be heard and to shape how we think about reproductive ethics.
The Role of Coercion in Adoption and Surrogacy
Coercion in adoption and surrogacy is often subtle, cloaked in the language of choice and empowerment. But for many women, especially those facing poverty, homelessness, or abuse, there is no real choice. Adoption may be presented as the only responsible option. Surrogacy may be marketed as a way to escape poverty. In both cases, the conditions that lead to these decisions are rarely addressed.
One young woman shared how her counsellor framed adoption as a noble sacrifice, leaving her feeling she had no alternative. She later realized that what she needed was housing and childcare, not separation from her baby. Another surrogate from a low-income community recounted how she was promised generous compensation and medical care, only to be left with complications and emotional trauma.
These scenarios reveal systemic failures. Instead of supporting women to parent or pursue safe, dignified alternatives to surrogacy, society often exploits their vulnerability. The result is a system that serves the needs of the powerful while disregarding the humanity of those who are most affected.
Commodification: Children and Women as Products
At its most disturbing, adoption and surrogacy have become markets; industries driven by supply and demand. Children are advertised online, often with details about their health, race, or gender. Surrogacy agencies boast high success rates and customizable packages, sometimes including selective abortion clauses or gender selection options.[iii]
This commodification of human life is a profound ethical violation. Children are not products to be ordered, and women are not factories. When legal contracts dictate a surrogate’s behaviour, diet, or medical decisions, or when adoptive parents can “return” a child due to behavioural issues or disabilities, we have crossed a moral threshold. We have turned people into property.
Internationally, the risks are even greater. In countries with few legal protections, women are recruited to carry children for wealthy foreign clients, often under exploitative conditions. Some are misled about the nature of the arrangement; others are denied postnatal contact or left with no legal recourse. The children born into these systems may be denied citizenship, legal identity, or access to their biological roots.
Such practices are incompatible with a society that claims to value human dignity. They expose the urgent need for international oversight, ethical standards, and a fundamental rethinking of how we approach reproduction.
A Child-Centered Approach: Rights Over Desires
At the heart of this issue lies a critical question: whose rights are being prioritised? Too often, adult desires to become parents, to earn income, overshadow the rights of children to know their origins, remain with their mothers, and be protected from commodification.
The United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child emphasizes that every child has the right to identity, to family, and to be cared for by their parents whenever possible.[iv] Yet adoption and surrogacy frequently undermine these rights. Anonymous surrogacy arrangements, closed adoptions, and contracts that sever ties between child and birth mother all violate the spirit, if not the letter, of this convention.
A child-centred approach requires more than good intentions. It requires systems designed to preserve family connections, provide long-term emotional support, and prevent exploitation. It also requires humility; the recognition that some adult desires, however heartfelt, cannot ethically be fulfilled at the expense of others’ rights.
Reimagining Solutions: Family Preservation First
Rather than focusing on separating mothers and infants, we must invest in keeping families together. This means robust social support systems: access to healthcare, housing, mental health services, childcare, and parenting education. One single mother shared how a grant for rent and childcare allowed her to keep her baby, a decision that changed both their lives.[v] Without that support, she would have faced pressure to relinquish.
We must also change the narrative. Adoption and surrogacy should not be defaults or ideals; they should be last-resort responses to truly unresolvable situations. And when used, they must be transparent, ethical, and child-centred. This includes:
- Banning all surrogacy
- ‘Adoption’ policies that do not legally sever ties of a child to their biological roots
- Ensuring current adoptees have access to their records and biological families
- Mandating full disclosure and informed consent
Creating a Just Future: Honouring the Bond
The mother-infant bond is not a sentimental relic; it is a vital human connection with lifelong significance. When we sever this bond for convenience, profit, or ideology, we do more than harm individuals; we undermine the foundations of compassion, trust, and social justice.
A just society must protect the most vulnerable. Infants deserve to remain with their mothers whenever possible. Mothers deserve support, not separation. Children deserve truth, identity, and belonging.
By centering these values, and listening to those who have lived through adoption and surrogacy, we can reimagine a world where no one is forced to give up a child, and no child is forced to grow up without their first, deepest connection.
Together, we can shift from a system of separation to one of solidarity—where the mother-infant bond is honoured not just in word, but in action.
References
[i] Hepper, P. G. (1991). An examination of fetal learning before and after birth. Irish Journal of Psychology, 12(2), 95–107. https://doi.org/10.1080/03033910.1991.10557726
[ii] Winkler, R., & van Keppel, M. (1984). Relinquishing mothers in adoption: Their long-term adjustment. Institute of Family Studies.
[iii] Rudrappa, S. (2015). Discounted Life: The Price of Global Surrogacy in India. New York
[iv] United Nations. (1989). Convention on the Rights of the Child. Article 7. https://www.ohchr.org/en/instruments-mechanisms/instruments/convention-rights-child
[v] Rotabi, K. S., & Bromfield, N. F. (2017). Adoption and Child Trafficking: Ethics, Policy and Practice. Praeger.University Press.