I asked the question: “Based on everything you know about me from in here, and from the internet, how would you describe my political positioning?”

I can assess the political pattern in your publicly expressed views, but I would distinguish that from assigning you a political identity or party allegiance. I do not have a basis for saying, for example, that you are a Liberal, National, conservative, libertarian or anything else in the sense of personal political affiliation.

Looking at your writing, research, public advocacy and the discussions we have had here, however, there is a fairly distinctive political philosophy running through them.

I would describe your public positioning as socially conservative on some major moral questions, strongly civil-libertarian on questions of state and institutional power, and unusually resistant to fitting neatly into the conventional Australian left-right divide.

Where you clearly lean conservative

On abortion, your public record places you well outside contemporary progressive politics. You have opposed abortion liberalisation, particularly late-term abortion, argued for stronger safeguards and independent counselling, and spent many years examining abortion coercion and adverse experiences following abortion.

Your more recent concerns about gender ideology, women’s sex-based rights and aspects of the sexualisation of children would ordinarily also be classified as socially conservative positions.

Your LinkedIn activity, for example, includes criticism of policies concerning males who identify as women and women’s protection.

So if somebody encountered only those issues, they would probably place you on the political right.

But I think that would give a rather incomplete picture.

Where you depart from conventional conservatism

There is a strong anti-authoritarian strand in your thinking.

Your Alarmist Gatekeeping work is fundamentally concerned with the ability of institutions to establish a dominant account of reality, control permissible language, exclude dissenting evidence and impose professional or social penalties upon people who depart from the accepted position. That is apparent in both the original academic theory and your subsequent writing.

That concern is not inherently conservative. Historically it belongs just as readily to liberalism and civil libertarianism.

Your COVID-era writing makes this particularly obvious. You were highly critical of restrictions on protest, interstate movement, lockdowns, government accountability and the economic consequences of government decisions.

The common thread therefore seems less like “government should enforce conservative values” and more like “institutions should have to justify the power they exercise over individuals.”

That is an important distinction.

There are also positions in your work that have traditionally belonged to the left

Your treatment of the Abyan case is a good example.

You opposed the assumption that a refugee woman who became pregnant following rape should necessarily proceed towards abortion, but you simultaneously condemned Australia’s treatment of refugees and described detention conditions as inhumane.

Likewise, your approach to adoption is difficult to categorise as conventionally conservative. Although adoption is often promoted within pro-life politics as the obvious alternative to abortion, you have become strongly critical of that message because of what you see as its implications for women, motherhood and mother-child separation.

That willingness to criticise your own “side” is politically significant.

The strongest thread I see is actually autonomy

There is a remarkable consistency between your older abortion work, Alarmist Gatekeeping, your counselling philosophy and your present work with the Autonomy Commission.

Again and again, the question seems to be:

Who gets to decide what another person needs, believes, says or does?

You are particularly suspicious when governments, professional organisations, ideological movements or helping professions claim that authority for themselves.

Even your approach to counselling follows the same pattern. You resist practitioners assuming responsibility for another person’s choices and outcomes. The emphasis is on agency, responsibility and avoiding the manufacture of dependency.

Politically, that places considerable weight on individual agency, freedom of conscience, freedom of expression, institutional restraint and pluralism.

There is an interesting tension in your position

Your views do not amount to straightforward libertarianism either.

A strict libertarian argument about abortion, for example, might simply prioritise the pregnant woman’s freedom from government interference. Your argument considers another human life to be involved and is also concerned about whether women’s decisions are genuinely autonomous when coercion, inadequate information or social pressure are present.

Likewise, you are not arguing that institutions should never establish boundaries. Much of your work concerns ethical responsibility and the consequences of choices.

So I would describe the underlying principle as closer to:

maximum personal autonomy consistent with responsibility towards other people.

That is different from both progressive autonomy, which can place considerable confidence in institutions to protect vulnerable groups, and pure libertarianism, which can give relatively little attention to relational obligations.

If I had to place you on a political map

I would expect a conventional one-dimensional left-right test to classify you somewhere on the right, largely because abortion, gender and related social questions carry enormous weighting in those tests.

A two-dimensional political test would probably produce something more interesting. I would expect you to fall right of centre socially/culturally but considerably more libertarian than authoritarian.

Yet even that misses something.

I think heterodox civil-libertarian with socially conservative positions is probably a more accurate descriptive label than simply “conservative”.

There is another description that may fit even better:

an autonomy-centred pluralist.

Your public work repeatedly accepts that people will hold very different beliefs. What you object to is one group acquiring enough institutional power to determine which beliefs may legitimately be expressed, investigated or acted upon.

That explains why apparently disparate subjects interest you. Abortion, COVID restrictions, gender, professional regulation, censorship, counselling practice, adoption and the Autonomy Commission look politically unrelated at first. Through the lens of agency versus institutional control, they are remarkably closely related.

And there is one final reason I would hesitate to call you simply “right wing”. Your criticism does not appear to be reserved for institutions controlled by people with whom you disagree. Some of your strongest criticism is directed towards practices and arguments within movements with which you otherwise share important convictions, particularly the pro-life movement’s treatment of adoption.

That suggests that your organising principle is less about political tribe and more about a fairly persistent suspicion of coercion, manufactured dependency, compelled conformity and unaccountable authority.

That, more than conventional conservatism, seems to me to be the political thread connecting your work.